Skip to Main Content
  • Carolina Pie Company logo top
    Carolina Pie Company logo scroll
  • Menu
  • Events
  • Order
  • Easter Orders
  • Catering
  • Join Our Team
  • Pie Classes
  • Go to top
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
Carolina Pie Company logo topCarolina Pie Company logo scroll
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • Menu
  • Events
  • Order
  • Easter Orders
  • Catering
  • Join Our Team
  • Pie Classes

Our Menu

Full Size Pies (9") to Order - 2 business day lead time

Limited Time Pies!

Grab one while they're here!

Fresh Strawberry photo

Fresh Strawberry

$35.00
AVAILABLE FRIDAYS & SATURDAYS ONLY in May - A half gallon of fresh sliced strawberries from Patterson Farm nestled in a house-made strawberry compote, set in our signature pastry crust and generously topped with vanilla whipped cream!

Take & Bake

Our Take & Bake pies are handcrafted from scratch, then frozen unbaked so you can finish them in your own oven filling your home with the smell and tastes of fresh pie!

Take & Bake Ol' Fashioned Apple

$25.00
Freshly peeled apples spiced with cinnamon, ginger & nutmeg finished with our signature pastry top crust – classic! | Gluten free option available

Take & Bake Red Tart Cherry

$28.00
Our homemade filling is perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness and tart red cherries finished with our signature pastry topcrust | Gluten free option available

Take & Bake Southern Peach

$28.00
Sun ripened peaches lightly spiced and finished with our signature pastry topcrust | Gluten free options available

Fruit Pies - Pastry Topped

Each pie is filled with homemade fruit fillings and topped with our signature pastry lattice or topcrust.

Ol' Fashioned Apple photo

Ol' Fashioned Apple

$32.00
Freshly peeled apples spiced with cinnamon, ginger & nutmeg baked with a signature pastry top crust – classic! | Gluten free and low sugar options available
Bumbleberry photo

Bumbleberry

$32.00
Strawberries, blueberries, raspberries & blackberries, a sprinkling of sugar and a pinch of spice, latticed with our signature pastry crust | Gluten free and low sugar options available
Strawberry Rhubarb - Seasonal photo

Strawberry Rhubarb - Seasonal

$32.00
Wildly popular when in season, sweet strawberries and tart rhubarb balance this pie perfectly - all baked in our signature pastry crust with your choice of pastry lattice or sweet brown sugar oat crumble | Gluten free options available
Sweet Strawberry photo

Sweet Strawberry

$32.00
Sunshine in a pie! Sweet springtime strawberries latticed with our signature pastry crust and baked to perfection | April - September | Gluten free and low sugar options available
Southern Peach photo

Southern Peach

$35.00
Sun ripened peaches lightly spiced and latticed with our signature pastry crust | Gluten free and low sugar options available | April - September
Red Tart Cherry photo

Red Tart Cherry

$35.00
Our homemade filling is perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness and tart red cherries latticed with our signature pastry crust | Gluten free option available
Wild Maine Blueberry photo

Wild Maine Blueberry

$32.00
Tiny wild Maine blueberries with just a touch of cinnamon, delicately latticed with our signature pastry crust | Gluten free and low sugar options available
Marionberry photo

Marionberry

$35.00
Marionberries, also known as "The King of Blackberries" sourced from Oregon, boast a sweet-tart flavor - perfect for pies. Baked with a touch of cinnamon and vanilla and topped with our signature pastry lattice | Gluten free option available

Fruit Pies - Crumble Topped

Our house made fillings topped with buttery crumble

Apple Crumble photo

Apple Crumble

$32.00
Freshly peeled cinnamon spiced apples topped with sweet, buttery crumble baked in our signature pastry crust | Gluten free option available
A.B.C. (Apple Berry Crumble) photo

A.B.C. (Apple Berry Crumble)

$32.00
Freshly peeled apples, blueberries, raspberries and blackberries topped with sweet, buttery crumble | Gluten free option available
Crumbleberry photo

Crumbleberry

$32.00
Strawberries, blueberries, raspberries & blackberries, a sprinkle of sugar and a pinch of spice, topped with our rustic brown sugar oat crumble | Gluten free options available
Cherry Crumble photo

Cherry Crumble

$35.00
Our homemade filling is perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness and tart red cherries elevated with our very own coconut almond crumble
Peach Crumble photo

Peach Crumble

$35.00
Lightly spiced sun ripened peaches baked in our signature pastry crust and elevated with our very own coconut-almond crumble

Cream Pies

Our creamy, scratch-made fillings, nestled in a variety of crusts and finished with fresh whipped cream.

Chocolate Cream photo

Chocolate Cream

$32.00
Rich homemade chocolate custard set in our signature pastry crust, topped with fresh whipped cream and a sprinkle of chocolate shavings | Gluten free option available
Coconut Cream photo

Coconut Cream

$32.00
Flaked coconut blended throughout our homemade vanilla custard set in our signature pastry crust and topped with fresh whipped cream and toasted coconut flakes | Gluten free option available
Key Lime photo

Key Lime

$32.00
Key lime juice sourced from Key West gives this pie its trademark tart flavor set in our house made honey graham crust, laced with fresh whipped cream and a sprinkle of lime zest
Atlantic Beach photo

Atlantic Beach

$32.00
Originating from the coast of NC, a light and tangy lemon custard set in a buttery saltine crust topped with fresh whipped cream and a sprinkle of lemon zest
Banana Pudding photo

Banana Pudding

$32.00
Fresh bananas throughout our extra creamy house made vanilla pudding set in our signature pastry crust and laced with fresh whipped cream - welcome to the South! | Gluten free option available

Ice Cream Pies

Made with rich cream and a variety of flavor options, these pies are a refreshing option for now, or store in the freezer for later!

Frozen Peanut Butter photo

Frozen Peanut Butter

$35.00
A creamy peanut butter ice cream pie set in a decadent crust of chopped peanuts and mini chocolate chips. Gluten free and plentiful, it easily serves a large crowd!
Frozen Margarita photo

Frozen Margarita

$35.00
Creamy, zesty lime ice cream filling spiked with Jose Cuervo Gold® tequila and orange liqueur, set in a buttery salted pretzel crust and finished with a sprinkle of lime zest
Frozen Mudslide photo

Frozen Mudslide

$35.00
This pie is dangerously delicious! Whipped cream, cream cheese, and just the right amount of 🍀Baileys® Irish Cream🍀 are the stars of this silky filling, nestled in a chocolate cookie crust and finished with fresh whipped cream and a chocolate swirl.
Frozen Nutella photo

Frozen Nutella

$35.00
Rich and smooth chocolate hazelnut ice cream set in a chocolate cookie crust and topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle | Gluten free option available
Frozen Lemonade photo

Frozen Lemonade

$35.00
A refreshingly cool and creamy treat, citrusy lemonade filling with whipped cream gently folded in and set in our house made honey graham crust and finished with a sprinkling of lemon zest - perfect for a summer cookout treat!

Custard Pies

The classics...rich, gooey and oh so delicious!

Pecan photo

Pecan

$30.00
The perfect blend of sweet and toasty, silky and crunchy, smooth browned butter, warm vanilla and spicy cinnamon baked in our signature pastry crust | Gluten free option available
Bourbon Pecan photo

Bourbon Pecan

$32.00
Elevate our classic pecan pie with a douse of smoky bourbon | Gluten free option available
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan photo

Chocolate Bourbon Pecan

$32.00
A decadent twist on the classic pecan, this rich, gooey pie combines a pecan crunch with chocolate melted into the filling, topped with a shot of Kentucky Bourbon and baked in our signature pastry crust | Gluten free option available
Roasted Sweet Potato photo

Roasted Sweet Potato

$28.00

Chess Pies

A true Southern treat, simple, nostalgic, and just the right amount of indulgent—like a warm hug from Grandma’s kitchen

Chocolate Chess photo

Chocolate Chess

$28.00
Rich, decadent chocolate filling - imagine a silky smooth fudgy brownie - baked in our signature pastry crust - a must try for chocolate lovers!
Lemon Chess photo

Lemon Chess

$28.00
A Southern favorite balancing tart and sweet, zesty lemon and smooth texture, perfectly baked in our signature pastry crust
Coconut Chess photo

Coconut Chess

$28.00
This smooth filling is made with sweet coconut and a hint of vanilla, baked in our signature pastry crust
Buttermilk photo

Buttermilk

$28.00
Sweet, tangy and creamy buttermilk with a hint of nutmeg and a heap of nostalgia baked in our signature pastry crust
  • Order
  • Pie Classes
  • Catering