Skip to Main Content
  • Carolina Pie Company logo top
    Carolina Pie Company logo scroll
  • Thanksgiving Pre-Orders
  • *
  • *
  • *
  • *
  • Catering requests
  • Future Order - Full menu
  • *
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
Carolina Pie Company logo topCarolina Pie Company logo scroll
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • Thanksgiving Pre-Orders
  • *
  • *
  • *
  • *
  • Catering requests
  • Future Order - Full menu
  • *

Our Menu

Full Size Pies (9") to Order - 2 business day lead time

Take & Bake

Our Take & Bake pies are handcrafted from scratch, then frozen unbaked so you can finish them in your own oven filling your home with the smell and tastes of fresh pie!

Take & Bake Ol' Fashioned Apple

$25.00
Freshly peeled apples spiced with cinnamon, ginger & nutmeg finished with our signature pastry top crust – classic! | Gluten free option available

Take & Bake Red Tart Cherry

$28.00
Our homemade filling is perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness and tart red cherries finished with our signature pastry topcrust | Gluten free option available

Fruit Pies - Pastry Topped

Each pie is filled with homemade fruit fillings and topped with our signature pastry lattice or topcrust.

Ol' Fashioned Apple photo

Ol' Fashioned Apple

$32.00
Freshly peeled apples spiced with cinnamon, ginger & nutmeg baked with a signature pastry top crust – classic! | Gluten free and low sugar options available
Bumbleberry photo

Bumbleberry

$32.00
Strawberries, blueberries, raspberries & blackberries, a sprinkling of sugar and a pinch of spice, latticed with our signature pastry crust | Gluten free and low sugar options available
Red Tart Cherry photo

Red Tart Cherry

$35.00
Our homemade filling is perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness and tart red cherries latticed with our signature pastry crust | Gluten free option available
Wild Maine Blueberry photo

Wild Maine Blueberry

$32.00
Tiny wild Maine blueberries with just a touch of cinnamon, delicately latticed with our signature pastry crust | Gluten free and low sugar options available
Marionberry photo

Marionberry

$35.00
Marionberries, also known as "The King of Blackberries" sourced from Oregon, boast a sweet-tart flavor - perfect for pies. Baked with a touch of cinnamon and vanilla and topped with our signature pastry lattice | Gluten free option available

Fruit Pies - Crumble Topped

Our house made fillings topped with buttery crumble

Apple Crumble photo

Apple Crumble

$32.00
Freshly peeled cinnamon spiced apples topped with sweet, buttery crumble baked in our signature pastry crust | Gluten free option available
A.B.C. (Apple Berry Crumble) photo

A.B.C. (Apple Berry Crumble)

$32.00
Freshly peeled apples, blueberries, raspberries and blackberries topped with sweet, buttery crumble | Gluten free option available
Crumbleberry photo

Crumbleberry

$32.00
Strawberries, blueberries, raspberries & blackberries, a sprinkle of sugar and a pinch of spice, topped with our rustic brown sugar oat crumble | Gluten free options available
Cherry Crumble photo

Cherry Crumble

$35.00
Our homemade filling is perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness and tart red cherries elevated with our very own coconut almond crumble
Apple Cranberry Crumble photo

Apple Cranberry Crumble

$32.00
Freshly peeled apples, spiced and laced with cranberries and pecans, topped with sweet, buttery crumble and baked in our signature pastry crust

Marionberry Crumble

$35.00
Marionberries, also known as "The King of Blackberries" sourced from Oregon, boast a sweet-tart flavor - perfect for pies. Baked with a touch of cinnamon and vanilla and topped topped with our rustic brown sugar oat crumble | Gluten free options available

Cream Pies

Our creamy, scratch-made fillings, nestled in a variety of crusts and finished with fresh whipped cream.

Chocolate Cream photo

Chocolate Cream

$32.00
Rich homemade chocolate custard set in our signature pastry crust, topped with fresh whipped cream and a sprinkle of chocolate shavings | Gluten free option available
Coconut Cream photo

Coconut Cream

$32.00
Flaked coconut blended throughout our homemade vanilla custard set in our signature pastry crust and topped with fresh whipped cream and toasted coconut flakes | Gluten free option available
Key Lime photo

Key Lime

$32.00
Key lime juice sourced from Key West gives this pie its trademark tart flavor set in our house made honey graham crust, laced with fresh whipped cream and a sprinkle of lime zest
Banana Pudding photo

Banana Pudding

$32.00
Fresh bananas throughout our extra creamy house made vanilla pudding set in our signature pastry crust and laced with fresh whipped cream - welcome to the South! | Gluten free option available
Pumpkin Cream photo

Pumpkin Cream

$32.00
Extra creamy house made pumpkin spice pudding set in a gingersnap cookie crust and topped with brown sugar whipped cream
Chocolate Espresso Cream photo

Chocolate Espresso Cream

$32.00
Silky chocolate pudding made with melted chocolate and a few shots of espresso, topped with our mocha whipped cream set in our signature pastry crust
Peanut Butter Cream photo

Peanut Butter Cream

$32.00
Creamy house made peanut butter filling set in a chocolate cookie crust and topped with fresh whipped cream and a sprinkling of chopped peanuts - tastes like a Nutter Butter! | Gluten free option available

Ice Cream Pies

Made with rich cream and a variety of flavor options, these pies are a refreshing option for now, or store in the freezer for later!

Frozen Peanut Butter photo

Frozen Peanut Butter

$35.00
A creamy peanut butter ice cream pie set in a decadent crust of chopped peanuts and mini chocolate chips. Gluten free and plentiful, it easily serves a large crowd!
Frozen Margarita photo

Frozen Margarita

$35.00
Creamy, zesty lime ice cream filling spiked with Jose Cuervo Gold® tequila and orange liqueur, set in a buttery salted pretzel crust and finished with a sprinkle of lime zest
Frozen Mudslide photo

Frozen Mudslide

$35.00
This pie is dangerously delicious! Whipped cream, cream cheese, and just the right amount of 🍀Baileys® Irish Cream🍀 are the stars of this silky filling, nestled in a chocolate cookie crust and finished with fresh whipped cream and a chocolate swirl.
Frozen Nutella photo

Frozen Nutella

$35.00
Rich and smooth chocolate hazelnut ice cream set in a chocolate cookie crust and topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle | Gluten free option available
Frozen Lemonade photo

Frozen Lemonade

$35.00
A refreshingly cool and creamy treat, citrusy lemonade filling with whipped cream gently folded in and set in our house made honey graham crust and finished with a sprinkling of lemon zest - perfect for a summer cookout treat!

Custard Pies

The classics...rich, gooey and oh so delicious!

Pecan photo

Pecan

$30.00
The perfect blend of sweet and toasty, silky and crunchy, smooth browned butter, warm vanilla and spicy cinnamon baked in our signature pastry crust | Gluten free option available
Bourbon Pecan photo

Bourbon Pecan

$32.00
Elevate our classic pecan pie with a douse of smoky bourbon | Gluten free option available
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan photo

Chocolate Bourbon Pecan

$32.00
A decadent twist on the classic pecan, this rich, gooey pie combines a pecan crunch with chocolate melted into the filling, topped with a shot of Kentucky Bourbon and baked in our signature pastry crust | Gluten free option available
Buttermilk photo

Buttermilk

$28.00
Roasted Sweet Potato photo

Roasted Sweet Potato

$28.00
Kentucky Derby photo

Kentucky Derby

$28.00
Made popular by the Kentucky Derby, it's a custard-like chocolate chip pecan cookie in pie form. Add a shot of bourbon and you're off to the races!

Chess Pies

A true Southern treat, simple, nostalgic, and just the right amount of indulgent—like a warm hug from Grandma’s kitchen

Chocolate Chess photo

Chocolate Chess

$28.00
Rich, decadent chocolate filling - imagine a silky smooth fudgy brownie - baked in our signature pastry crust - a must try for chocolate lovers!
Lemon Chess photo

Lemon Chess

$28.00
A Southern favorite balancing tart and sweet, zesty lemon and smooth texture, perfectly baked in our signature pastry crust
Coconut Chess photo

Coconut Chess

$28.00
This smooth filling is made with sweet coconut and a hint of vanilla, baked in our signature pastry crust
  • Order
  • Pie Classes
  • Catering