Our Menu
We stock these flavors daily in 9" and 4" Cutie Pies at our shop until they are sold out for the day. There's always a delicious pie waiting for you - but to secure a particular flavor, we recommend placing an order! (Cutie Pies $6 ea.)
*****
Special! Frozen Margarita Pie
$35.00
Creamy, zesty lime ice cream filling spiked with Jose Cuervo Gold® tequila and orange liqueur, set in a buttery salted pretzel crust and finished with a sprinkle of lime zest
Special! Kentucky Derby Pie
$28.00
Made popular by the Kentucky Derby, it's a custard-like chocolate chip pecan cookie in pie form. Add a shot of bourbon and you're off to the races!
A.B.C. (Apple Berry Crumble)
$32.00
Freshly peeled apples, blueberries, raspberries and blackberries topped with sweet, buttery crumble | Gluten free option available
Ol' Fashioned Apple
$32.00
Freshly peeled apples spiced with cinnamon, ginger & nutmeg baked with a signature pastry top crust – classic! | Gluten free and low sugar options available
Crumbleberry
$32.00
Strawberries, blueberries, raspberries & blackberries, a sprinkle of sugar and a pinch of spice, topped with our rustic brown sugar oat crumble | Gluten free options available
Chocolate Cream
$32.00
Rich homemade chocolate custard set in our signature pastry crust, topped with fresh whipped cream and a sprinkle of chocolate shavings | Gluten free option available
Coconut Cream
$32.00
Flaked coconut blended throughout our homemade vanilla custard set in our signature pastry crust and topped with fresh whipped cream and toasted coconut flakes | Gluten free option available
Key Lime
$32.00
Key lime juice sourced from Key West gives this pie its trademark tart flavor set in our house made honey graham crust, laced with fresh whipped cream and a sprinkle of lime zest
Pecan
$30.00
The perfect blend of sweet and toasty, silky and crunchy, smooth browned butter, warm vanilla and spicy cinnamon baked in our signature pastry crust | Gluten free option available
Chocolate Chess
$28.00
Rich, decadent chocolate filling - imagine a silky smooth fudgy brownie - baked in our signature pastry crust - a must try for chocolate lovers!
SEASONAL! Strawberry Rhubarb
$32.00
Wildly popular when in season, sweet strawberries and tart rhubarb balance this pie perfectly - all baked in our signature pastry crust with your choice of pastry lattice or sweet brown sugar oat crumble | Gluten free options available
Roasted Sweet Potato
$28.00
Roasted sugary sweet potatoes, spiced with cinnamon and clove, baked in our signature pastry crust. A Southern staple with a rich heritage – this pie is here to stay!
Bumbleberry
$32.00
Strawberries, blueberries, raspberries & blackberries, a sprinkling of sugar and a pinch of spice, latticed with our signature pastry crust | Gluten free and low sugar options available
Wild Maine Blueberry
$32.00
Tiny wild Maine blueberries with just a touch of cinnamon, delicately latticed with our signature pastry crust | Gluten free and low sugar options available
Apple Crumble
$32.00
Freshly peeled cinnamon spiced apples topped with sweet, buttery crumble baked in our signature pastry crust | Gluten free option available
SEASONAL! Atlantic Beach
$32.00
Originating from the coast of NC, a light and tangy lemon custard set in a buttery saltine crust topped with fresh whipped cream and a sprinkle of lemon zest | April - September
Banana Pudding
$32.00
Fresh bananas throughout our extra creamy house made vanilla pudding set in our signature pastry crust and laced with fresh whipped cream - welcome to the South! | Gluten free option available
Bourbon Pecan
$32.00
Elevate our classic pecan pie with a douse of smoky bourbon | Gluten free option available
Lemon Chess
$28.00
A Southern favorite balancing tart and sweet, zesty lemon and smooth texture, perfectly baked in our signature pastry crust
Frozen Peanut Butter
$35.00
A creamy peanut butter ice cream pie set in a decadent crust of chopped peanuts and mini chocolate chips. Gluten free and plentiful, it easily serves a large crowd!
Specialty pies are made just for you - you won’t find them on the store shelf so be sure to submit your order and we'll be right on it - they are worth the wait! Available in 9" and 4" Cutie Pies (Specialty Cutie Pie orders with minimum of 4/flavor - $6 ea.)
*****
Tart Red Cherry
$35.00
Our homemade filling is perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness and tart red cherries latticed with our signature pastry crust | Gluten free option available
Cherry Crumble
$35.00
Our homemade filling is perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness and tart red cherries elevated with our very own coconut almond crumble
Lemon Meringue
$35.00
Made to order only by our head baker - Tart lemon curd set in our signature pastry crust topped with fluffy Italian meringue and lightly torched because this pie loves drama! | Gluten free option available
Marion Blackberry
$35.00
Marion blackberries sprinkled with sugar and a touch of vanilla & cinnamon, latticed with our signature pastry crust | Gluten free and low sugar options available
SEASONAL! Southern Peach
$35.00
Sun ripened peaches, sugar and spice and everything nice, latticed with our signature pastry crust | Gluten free and low sugar options available | April - September
SEASONAL! Peach Crumble
$35.00
Lightly spiced sun ripened peaches baked in our signature pastry crust and elevated with our very own coconut-almond crumble
SEASONAL! Sweet Strawberry
$32.00
Sunshine in a pie! Sweet springtime strawberries latticed with our signature pastry crust and baked to perfection | April - September | Gluten free and low sugar options available
Blueberry - Peach
$32.00
Sun ripened peaches and juicy blueberries are a perfect summer pair, their natural goodness dusted with a hint of cinnamon, baked and latticed in our signature pastry crust | Gluten free and low sugar options available
Blackberry-Peach Crumble
$35.00
Marion blackberries and sun ripened peaches dusted with cinnamon and topped with our sweet brown sugar oat crumble | April - August
These flavors are lovingly stored away in the pantry this week - but be on the lookout for your favorite flavor to come out of the pantry and make an appearance on our shop menu! Sign up for our newsletter to be the first to know which flavors are coming off the pantry shelf next!
*****
Chocolate Pecan
$30.00
A decadent twist on the classic pecan, this rich, gooey pie combines a pecan crunch with a fudgy chocolate filling baked in our signature pastry crust | Gluten free option available
Coconut Chess
$28.00
A Southern classic - this smooth custard filling is made with sweet coconut and a hint of vanilla, baked in our signature pastry crust
German Chocolate
$30.00
A smooth milk chocolate pie topped with roasted pecans and toasted coconut baked in our signature pastry crust
Buttermilk
$28.00
Sweet, tangy and creamy buttermilk with a hint of nutmeg and a heap of nostalgia baked in our signature pastry crust
Derby
$28.00
Made popular by the Kentucky Derby, it's a gooey chocolate chip pecan cookie in pie form. Add a shot of bourbon and you're off to the races!
SEASONAL! Strawberry Rhubarb
$32.00
Sweet strawberries, tart rhubarb and a pinch of nutmeg latticed with our signature pastry crust | May - July | Gluten free and low sugar options available
Chocolate Espresso Cream
$32.00
Silky chocolate espresso custard, set in our signature pastry crust and topped with fresh mocha whipped cream and dusted with cocoa | Gluten free option available
SEASONAL! Frozen Lemonade
$35.00
A refreshingly cool and creamy treat, citrusy lemonade filling with whipped cream gently folded in and set in our house made honey graham crust and finished with a sprinkling of lemon zest - perfect for a summer cookout treat! | June - September
Frozen Margarita
$35.00
Creamy, zesty lime filling set in a salted pretzel crust, spiked with Jose Cuervo® tequila and orange liqueur - Taco Tuesday can't come quick enough!