Our Menu
We stock these flavors daily in 9" and 4" Cutie Pies at our shop until they are sold out for the day. There's always a delicious pie waiting for you - but to secure a particular flavor, we recommend placing an order! (Cutie Pies $6 ea.)
*****

A.B.C. (Apple Berry Crumble)

Ol' Fashioned Apple

Crumbleberry

Chocolate Cream

Coconut Cream

Key Lime

Pecan

Chocolate Chess

Roasted Sweet Potato

Bumbleberry

Wild Maine Blueberry

Apple Crumble

SEASONAL! Atlantic Beach

Banana Pudding

Bourbon Pecan

Lemon Chess

Frozen Peanut Butter
Specialty pies are made just for you - you won’t find them on the store shelf so be sure to submit your order and we'll be right on it - they are worth the wait! Available in 9" and 4" Cutie Pies (Specialty Cutie Pie orders with minimum of 4/flavor - $6 ea.)
*****

Tart Red Cherry

Cherry Crumble
Lemon Meringue

Marion Blackberry

SEASONAL! Southern Peach

SEASONAL! Peach Crumble
SEASONAL! Sweet Strawberry
Bueberry - Peach
Blackberry-Peach Crumble
These flavors are lovingly stored away in the pantry this week - but be on the lookout for your favorite flavor to come out of the pantry and make an appearance on our shop menu! Sign up for our newsletter to be the first to know which flavors are coming off the pantry shelf next!
*****

Chocolate Pecan

Coconut Chess

German Chocolate

Buttermilk

Derby
SEASONAL! Strawberry Rhubarb
